Marketing anti-patterns and solutions
Background
§ Quick history:
Marketing has progressed from broadcast (Mad Men) to personalization
(Amazon) to social (Facebook) to storytelling (Cupertino Fruit Company)
§ The
fundamentals from earlier phases never become irrelevant (message, audience,
creative, and measurement)
·
Patterns:
An overloaded term used in different ways in software, music, and
math. My usage is most closely aligned
with the software definition – a
generic solution.
·
Many functions, disciplines and roles referenced
below
§ Inform
about career opportunities -- adjacent to and specializations within Marketing
§ Build
acumen about what specialists to involve in a particular project
Two dysfunctional traps and their mitigations
Inertia
anti-pattern
§ If
you land a marketing job, how can you tell if it’s a good one?
§ Common
benchmarks to compare marketing jobs: budget, resources, and scope
§ There
is an incentive for marketing professionals to secure and maintain large
budgets
§ Budget
caution: Some marketing spends arise
from tradition, inertia or to make managers feel good. Spends must be challenged.
§
Remedy: Metrics are means to determine past success
and confirm future plans
§ Data
to information to knowledge to wisdom
§ A/B
testing over time example: Virtual
Account Manager (Personalized messages delivered via homepage)
·
Underutilized software capability for a members
only reseller site
·
Two years testing message only, not list and not creative
·
SRSs of 2K users
·
Brief, clickable calls to action only (no images
or creative)
·
Post view and click results centrally
·
Reward agencies with the highest CTRs
·
Publicize the BKM internally
§ Benchmarking
example: Cost per impression
·
Compared online campaign budgets of an MNC to a
local startup
·
How do you calculate cost per impression?
·
What is the difference between CTR and cost per
impression?
·
Local startup had much lower costs per
impression
·
Reasons for the advantage
o Low
direct costs due to volunteerism and start up privilege
o Lower
overhead costs such as brand compliance, technical integration complexity,
security, and contingent worker sponsorship practices
o Why
market for a big company? Specialization
and resources which can be leveraged over long time periods
Walk through - Marketing metrics data models
§ Two
data model examples demonstrate the complexity of marketing analytics
§ What
is a data model? Another overloaded term
§ Value
of the database design model?
§ How
did I use the models presented?
§ Difference
between statistical models and database design models?
§ How
do you create a database design model?
What skills are needed? Process
used?
What other anti-patterns might a
model like the ones above address?
1. Disparate
metric definitions used for message/campaigns indicators
a. Solution: Centralize metadata including entity names
and definitions
2. Disparate
systems with performance data
a. Solution: Map physical to logical
3. Difficulty
ramping less experience employees
a. Solution: Create knowledge artifacts that explain an
organization’s worldview
4. Getting
assigned a task that sounds easy, but is actually complex
a. Illustrating
complexity and dependency with a diagram
5. Too
much restricted IP makes industry discussion and university lecture difficult
a. Solution: ER diagrams can be shared, but budgets and
marketing plans cannot be shared
What other traps should we be aware
of?
Over-reliance
on core domain anti-pattern
§ With
so many examples of technologically sophisticated websites, isn’t it true that
technical limitations rarely constrain marketing strategy?
§ abc.com
attracts visitors and delivers content in established ways
§ There
are always limitations of core site’s technology, implementation, development
resources, agility, and/or flexibility
§ The
established methods and capabilities hamper innovation and fail to connect with
many customer journeys
·
Remedy: Marketing microsites
§ Context
– Big vs small company
§ Characteristics
§ Off
domain or start-up domain
§ Potentially
outside of the core Content Management System (CMS)
§ Focused
on a campaign or discrete subject area
§ Trade-offs
– Maintenance, brand dilution, and fractured measurement
§ When
to utilize
§ Joint
venture
§ Need
to move quickly
§ Test
a new message or a brand when the core site can’t catch up
§ Need
app capability and the core CMS doesn’t accommodate
Backup
·
What is the difference between Marketing and
Operations?
·
What is the difference between Advertising and
Marketing?
·
What college majors have the best chance of
getting a job in Competitive Intelligence or Competitive Strategy?
Comments
Post a Comment