Marketing anti-patterns and solutions



Background

§        Quick history:  Marketing has progressed from broadcast (Mad Men) to personalization (Amazon) to social (Facebook) to storytelling (Cupertino Fruit Company)
§  The fundamentals from earlier phases never become irrelevant (message, audience, creative, and measurement)
·         Patterns:  An overloaded term used in different ways in software, music, and math.  My usage is most closely aligned with the software definition – a generic solution.
·         Many functions, disciplines and roles referenced below
§  Inform about career opportunities -- adjacent to and specializations within Marketing
§  Build acumen about what specialists to involve in a particular project






Two dysfunctional traps and their mitigations


Inertia anti-pattern

§  If you land a marketing job, how can you tell if it’s a good one?
§  Common benchmarks to compare marketing jobs:  budget, resources, and scope
§  There is an incentive for marketing professionals to secure and maintain large budgets
§  Budget caution:  Some marketing spends arise from tradition, inertia or to make managers feel good.  Spends must be challenged.
§  Remedy:  Metrics are means to determine past success and confirm future plans
§  Data to information to knowledge to wisdom
§  A/B testing over time example:  Virtual Account Manager (Personalized messages delivered via homepage)
·         Underutilized software capability for a members only reseller site
·         Two years testing message only, not list and not creative
·         SRSs of 2K users
·         Brief, clickable calls to action only (no images or creative)
·         Post view and click results centrally
·         Reward agencies with the highest CTRs
·         Publicize the BKM internally
§  Benchmarking example:  Cost per impression
·         Compared online campaign budgets of an MNC to a local startup
·         How do you calculate cost per impression?
·         What is the difference between CTR and cost per impression?
·         Local startup had much lower costs per impression
·         Reasons for the advantage
o   Low direct costs due to volunteerism and start up privilege
o   Lower overhead costs such as brand compliance, technical integration complexity, security, and contingent worker sponsorship practices
o   Why market for a big company?  Specialization and resources which can be leveraged over long time periods

Walk through - Marketing metrics data models

§  Two data model examples demonstrate the complexity of marketing analytics
§  What is a data model?   Another overloaded term
§  Value of the database design model? 
§  How did I use the models presented?
§  Difference between statistical models and database design models?
§  How do you create a database design model?  What skills are needed?  Process used?

What other anti-patterns might a model like the ones above address?
1.       Disparate metric definitions used for message/campaigns indicators
a.       Solution:  Centralize metadata including entity names and definitions
2.       Disparate systems with performance data
a.       Solution:  Map physical to logical
3.       Difficulty ramping less experience employees
a.       Solution:  Create knowledge artifacts that explain an organization’s worldview
4.       Getting assigned a task that sounds easy, but is actually complex
a.       Illustrating complexity and dependency with a diagram
5.       Too much restricted IP makes industry discussion and university lecture difficult
a.       Solution:  ER diagrams can be shared, but budgets and marketing plans cannot be shared

What other traps should we be aware of?

Over-reliance on core domain anti-pattern

§  With so many examples of technologically sophisticated websites, isn’t it true that technical limitations rarely constrain marketing strategy?
§  abc.com attracts visitors and delivers content in established ways
§  There are always limitations of core site’s technology, implementation, development resources, agility, and/or flexibility
§  The established methods and capabilities hamper innovation and fail to connect with many customer journeys
·         Remedy:  Marketing microsites
§  Context – Big vs small company
§  Characteristics
§  Off domain or start-up domain
§  Potentially outside of the core Content Management System (CMS)
§  Focused on a campaign or discrete subject area
§  Trade-offs – Maintenance, brand dilution, and fractured measurement
§  When to utilize
§  Joint venture
§  Need to move quickly
§  Test a new message or a brand when the core site can’t catch up
§  Need app capability and the core CMS doesn’t accommodate



Backup
·         What is the difference between Marketing and Operations?
·         What is the difference between Advertising and Marketing?
·         What college majors have the best chance of getting a job in Competitive Intelligence or Competitive Strategy?

Comments